The paradox of positive thinking

Positive Thinking POS

It’s everywhere, isn’t it? The power of positive thinking.

It will solve all of our problems, it seems to say. We are told to, “Look on the bright side,” “Think positively,” “Cultivate gratitude,”…

While these can be helpful to help us correct gross imbalances of negativity, it isn’t actually the whole answer to a life well-lived.

We’ve all had that friend, coworker or family member that no matter the circumstances, they could make out a silver lining, no matter how faint. While at times it may be comforting and refreshing, hasn’t it sometimes been annoying? Weren’t we looking for a little commiseration and self-pity, for pete’s sake? I totally own it, I still enjoy a pity party once in a while, and a b%tch session with close acquaintances or friends.

Yet, don’t get me wrong. I had jumped on the “positive thinking,” law of attraction lifestyle theory bandwagon along with everyone else. I worried that dwelling on things that were upsetting or participating in a conversation where we only expressed negative experiences and feelings was a transgression. I felt guilty.

Have you?

That’s why I wanted to share this interesting article came out this week. It focuses on a Danish psychology professor at Aalborg University who was interviewed about the new cultural stigma of “being negative.”

Basically, we are human. As such, we experience a wide range of emotions from day to day. What can be stressful is when we experience a natural reaction of sadness, frustration or anger and then censure and convince ourselves that we should only think or be “positive.” We have become uncomfortable around people experiencing fear, loss, loneliness, etc., that it becomes our job to help “turn that smile upside down” – even if that person is ourselves. Because no one wants to be around someone like that, right? We don’t want to “bring everyone else down.”

But seriously – if someone walked around smiling and happy all of the time, wouldn’t that be creepy? Think clowns. Yeah, exactly.

We’ve come to equate “positive thinking” with emotional health. Emotions are gut reactions that happen in our body. Thoughts, on the other hand, we have complete control over. The paradox is that in our struggle to “think positively,” we have begun to talk or think negatively to ourselves about our own natural human experiences. In truth, we have turned to disempowering our intuition, and putting ourselves down for “feeling” – well, anything other than total joy and happiness day in and day out.

The burden we carry around is the equation we believe there is between “thinking” positively and “feeling” happy. We’ve come to believe that if we are a little more stern with ourselves in being “positive,” we can wipe out feeling sad or lonely, overwhelmed or shamed.

Sound familiar? How’s that been working out for you? Not that good, huh? I’m there with you.

So think about it in this way:

Life is a spectrum of emotions, and there is no such thing as a positive emotion or negative or “bad” emotion – unless we tell ourselves it is, and suffer on account of it. And don’t think you’re the first person to fall into that trap. It seems uniquely human. The Buddhist philosophy has long studied and philosophized on the difference between pain and suffering. Pain, they explain, is usually a physical or emotional sting. We all have them from time to time. Suffering, on the other hand, is the attitude toward or in how you interpret the pain.

As the famous quote from Shakespeare’s “Hamlet” illustrates, “… for there is nothing either good or bad, but thinking makes it so.”

Feeling badly is not a sign that we are managing our lives badly: It simply means we are actually experiencing life. Conversely, we could be more cognizant in how we react to it.

So next time you feel not so positive, pat yourself on the back, ask for a foot rub, tell positivity to take a hike and ride the wave. Because you probably have a pretty darn good reason for feeling that way today. Showing yourself compassion in those down times is the quickest way to a positive, happy, balanced life.

Be well!




Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s